I was raised a Christian and stopped believing in my mid-twenties. But I’m a Christian now. And here’s why: I believe, because I decided to stay in the fight. I was determined from the beginning that I would not stop asking questions, that I would not settle for shallow peace in a trade for deep belief. I was determined to follow truth wherever that may lead me and I was unwilling to stop until I found belief in something.
Because the reality is, we all have faith. No one knows. Choosing so-called unbelief requires faith in chemistry and biology and an explosion that brought about rational minds and love and empathy over the course of billions of years. Maybe the truth is a mish mash of it all, but we’re all believing in something. So I decided to decide what I believed, not just let it happen to me.
And as it turns out, when we’re talking about the basics of how we got here and why we remain, after a lot of studying nothing made more sense to me than creative design. All of the science can convince me of how stars and atoms all got here through evolution alone. But when you talk about the gift of consciousness, the knowledge that we exist, rational thinking, a mother’s love, beauty, sacrifice, in my mind it all points to a creator. Thomas Merton says, “although it seems nonsensical, it makes more sense than anything else.”
So there I was, deciding that the only thing that made sense was God. So now what? The Bible only made sense to me because nothing else did. Reading the Old Testament would have made an atheist of me, saying God is good during a tragedy would have made an atheist out of me, even offering up a prayer got pretty damn close.
So instead, I was quiet and I went outside. For years, that was my spiritual journey. God makes sense to me in nature. I see the beauty and intricate design all around. My questions about his goodness, his involvement, how and when he speaks, the mind bending confusion of the church, they were all silenced on a hike. I didn’t know the details and maybe I wasn’t ready for them. But on a trail I believed.
At some point I knew God enough in the peace of the earth and decided to start reading books again. C.S. Lewis, G.K. Chesterton, Richard Rhor, Christian Wiman. They gave me language for this new faith I was discovering, this second simplicity, not born out of ignorance or youthful thinking but born out of surrender. I had done the searching and discovered I cannot know the answers, the question was, could I make my peace with that.
So I made a decision, I decided that if I’m going to believe in God, I’m going to live like it’s true. I was no longer interested in following the whims of my emotion and ever-fluctuating feelings about belief. I instead made a choice. I am going to be a Christian. For the first several years I believed every once in a while and most of time I was deciding to live like I believed. I had made a decision based on what I had deduced about the world around me and I mostly believed, which was good enough.
I would tell this story all of the time, because it was the best I could do. I would tell it as a doubting Thomas, someone who thought he got duped and everything he was living for wasn’t true, but who by the grace of God had seen the scars that made him believe. Thomas’s prayer when he sees is, “My Lord my God.” That prayer is my life’s prayer. It’s all I have to say, nothing more, nothing less. I’ll be praying that prayer every day for the rest of my life.
Then I went through suffering. The thing we avoid, the opposite of beauty, the opposite of good, so we say. And there, in the darkest darkness, I found God in a way that was outside of my rational decisions and thought life. It was there that I believed because I saw.
I still work to believe, but I guess I mostly believe now. Looks like I turned out to be a Christian afterall. After the deconstruction of my belief I spent years frantically searching for answers. But I didn’t find faith there, I found it in the practice of belief, I found it at the end of myself.
On most days I find the Christian faith to be true to me in my soul. I read the Bible, I fight it and I get mad about all the parts that don’t make sense, but I find wisdom there too. I pray now, a very silent prayer, but a deeper prayer than I’ve ever known. I often teach on the topic of believing the goodness of God in suffering and I believed it myself in the midst of great loss. I have moments where my chest splits open and I think, Oh God none of it’s true. But the unbelief comes less and less. It seems that by living like it’s true my soul found God.