I don’t know if you know this, but evangelical Christians of the 90’s took two things nearly more seriously than God himself - virginity and hating halloween.
It was evil, as was Harry Potter. It was about witches, ghosts, likely satan himself. The costumes were evil, the skulls, grotesque. The bats and spider webs and jack-o-lanterns were all a celebration of darkness, the opposite of God, we’re just going to say it, Halloween was basically a sin. Once my dad took me and my sisters trick-or-treating because we happened to be staying with him when Halloween landed. I think my parents liked to piss each other off and pretend like they just accidentally happened to do something that irritated the other. So my dad took us trick-or-treating. I still remember it, it was the one time in my childhood I went. I obviously loved it, other than the fact that my mom and God were looking upon me with disappointment, but honestly that shame was tempered by the pillowcase full of candy.
That was just one year though, the other years we only celebrated harvest because that was completely acceptable. Sub spiders for fall leaves and make the jack-o-lanterns smiling and BAM, God approves. We dressed up (no ghosts, no witches), we filled up bags of candy at the different booths (no saying trick-or-treat), we ate sweets until we were crazy little maniacs. I was a Hershey kiss once, a ballerina once, my mom ran the cotton candy machine, my friends and I almost got sick on the bounce house. We ran around under the big football stadium lights that they brought in, the kind that whirred from the use of a generator. It was always cold and it was weird being at school at night, like seeing a teacher at the mall. We ran around with freedom because everyone knew everyone and we played little fair games in the gym. The booths were sectioned off and there were hay bales everywhere. Throw the coin in the little bowl. Toss the ring onto the stick. Eat candy, play the game, eat a caramel apple, go get a face painting. It was always one of my favorite nights of the year.
Then it got even better when we got home because we had to be sneaky about not trick-or-treating. My Mom said that if you didn’t hand out candy but you had your lights on, your house would get egged. When I went to college and was deconstructing my childhood this was one of those things I rolled my eyes at, no on eggs your house for not giving out candy. And then my house got egged (!!!!) when I was with my infant daughter in the hospital one halloween a couple of years ago. So sorry sweet children, that I couldn’t give you cavity causing, halfway made of wax, slave owner empowering hershey’s, I was busy with my sick daughter. Get off my lawn you little brats! But I digress.
Because of the very real fear of being egged, we would shut our lights out and crawl around the house so no one knew we were home. In the pitch black we would be giggling as we fumbled down the stairs to get a treat. With whispered voices we hid from the evil on the streets and I loved it. Our home felt cozy and safe from all the spooky children on the cold October night. I remember filling up a piping hot bath and giggling in the warmth thinking, those kids have no idea we’re home, we got them good. It was almost better than trick-or-treating itself. There we were, creeping around our dark house dressed up like giant candy with buckets full of sweets that friends had passed out at the harvest festival. Not a thing like halloween, not. a. thing.